I have a cold that’s wallowing around in my chest like a melancholy yak on codeine and it’s slowed me down a bit, but Bernadette advises us to write through our fatigue, so here… I … go …
Kevin Davies, one of the most enthusiastic readers and perspicacious writers I know (in a community of enthusiastic readers and perspicacious writers), makes the following delightful characterization and sends along a question in response to my statement that “I loathe structure.”:
So: you hate structure but like, not form, but forms, is that correct? You do seem pro-forms but not inhibited or contained by them. I attacks on the mind sorry TAXONOMIZE you as counter-hegemonic lyric discourse with opals and ornithography liable at any moment to flip a coin and go postal on patriarchy, yeah that’s it.
[this para also from KD — sorry, I haven’t figured out how to format this blog properly yet and have forgotten my html, which I’d got pretty good at before the stupid injury two years ago. i’ll review it, I *promise*] Kept thinking of Alan Davies’s thing in Signage where he talks about hating structure. [“I, a private and concrete individual, hate structures, and if I reveal Form in my way, it is in order to defend myself.”] But the emphasis, as I think Alan would probably agree now, is on hate rather than structure. But what _about_ Alan? He is one of our mutual passions. His work, that is. Do you ever find him insufficiently “ornamental”? He seems to, at least sometimes, want to get at the stripped-down emotional “facts” of what’s in front of him to write, which to my Asperger-addled mind (truthfully, I could use a little _more_ Asperger) might put him at odds with your pro-ornament argument. (I wonder how “pro-ornament” would come out on the software.)
[Nada again] I’m happy to report that “pro-ornament” came out as “pro ornament”, hyphen-less but accurate. But what _about_ Alan, indeed? To talk about him and ornament in the same mental breath I’m seeing that I need to hone my terms a little better. Either that or expand them to define “ornamental ™” (if I really am going to latch on to that term and make it “mine” — ugh) as “what I like”. Maybe I need to clear up the misconception that “ornamental” always means “frou-frou.” I’m not using “frou-frou” pejoratively — I’m one of the few people I know who actually *likes* Fragonard — but just as a delimiter of a certain kind of ornamentation. Actually, there’s a type of ornamentation I prefer that may be best exemplified by an anecdote:
The first time I went to France I had been living in Japan for a couple of years and was thoroughly imbued with Japanese sensibilities. I found the France I had dreamed of for so many years disappointing. I had been spoiled by the subtle asymmetries and striking combinations of elements that I lived among in Japan. The rococo gold ornamentation I saw in France seemed very “done”, almost dead, in comparison. I almost couldn’t see it. I’ve come to a more balanced appreciation of both European and Asian modes since I’ve come back to the USA (that is, give me anything but Americana, please!), but for the time I lived in Japan I was quite certain that there was no place where the objects were more beautiful.
Here’s a definition the Japanese notion of “kazari” (or “ornament”) from the British Museum web site:
The Japanese word kazari derives from the verb kazasu which means ‘to adorn the hair’. It has since developed to be widely used in contexts relating to decoration and display and is an integral part of the Japanese language and traditional aesthetics. …. The wit inherent in many of the designs suggests a sense of play, and often implies something beyond what is actually represented. Kazari extends to active participation in social activities such as tea and literary gatherings, seasonal festivals or even a visit to the brothel quarters as these events transmute the ordinary into the extraordinary. Kazari is an ephemeral sensation that through surprise and splendour can take you out of the everyday and elevate the mundane into the realm of the sacred.
From elsewhere on the site: “Kazari is defined by the scholar and pioneer of kazari studies, Tsuji Nobuo, as the ‘will to decorate’.
[Me again] My first entry of this blog begins with a sentence about the impulse to decorate, which rhymes very nicely with this definition. And while we’re on definitions, here are two of Webster’s — of “ornament” — that may help me to talk about Alan:
1: archaic: a useful accessory (This first definition is very usefully unpacked on Silva Rhetoricae: The Forest of Rhetoric web site [Thanks to Kasey Mohammad for showing me this wonderful resource]: “The ornaments of rhetoric are not extraneous; they are the equipment required to achieve the intended meaning or effect.”)
2: a: something that lends grace or beauty
Alan uses ornament judiciously, but that does not make him an “insufficiently ornamental” writer. If anything, that makes him a more efficient ornamentalist. He ornaments in the Japanese fashion, the way one would a tea-room, rather than in the be-tasseled, gaudy way that I perhaps am prone to. And often when I go back to his writings I notice that they are less austere than I remembered them. Here are some arguably ornamental examples from his writing, in the early middle, and contemporary periods. If you accept the “ephemeral sensation that through surprise and splendour can take you out of the everyday…” and “lends grace or beauty” definitions, then I may not have to struggle *too* much to fit him under my parasol:
Early (_Active 24 Hours_) 1982:
Coming, in parting this passage of time
proposes anklets for verbs, hierarchies
forming proportions, helping us home
….
Touring ardor or pacific languor talks
inventing equinox from dream, clearing head for
clarity specific language spots contain.
Never mind; these blousing anecdotes
tend within these trenchant anarchies
a penchant for more bluesy things to find.
from “Shared Sentences”
[Here, certain lexical choices signal ornament for me: “anklets”, “ardor”, “languor” put me in mind of the courtship of Rama and Sita. “Blousing” and “bluesy” re-evoke the “ardor” and “languor”. The poem decorates itself with mood. And the third stanza’s iambic pentameter, not to mention the internal rhyme of “trenchant” and “penchant”, refers to an earlier, more overtly ornamental verse tradition.]
………………………………………………………………………………………….
Middle (_Candor_,1990)
a deposit of archetypes against the skull
then longer lingual moments
watching them living embers
after raiding the kinetic panting forces
no static regain in the image field
ferns and tiger lilies indoors
adding quicksand to the loveliness
(from “F
U
E
L”)
[I find this passage ornamented not only by its choice of nouns — embers, ferns, tiger lilies, quicksand, loveliness — but also by its symphonic dynamics: static, elongated, glowing, ardent, and finally engulfing]
Poetry’s
thoughts with extra language in them
(from “A f t e r w a r d s”)
[This isn’t in and of itself ornamental but the concept is.]
[Plus, one of my favorite lines in all literature:]
Bunny haunches.
(from, I think — I can’t find my copy of this piece! — “Peer Pleasure” Sure wish I could quote it in context as its ornamental nature would be more evident, standing out from a bunch of flatter statements. But then again what’s more ornamental than bunny haunches? Can someone place this line for me?)
………………………………………………………………………………………….
Contemporary (from _Book 1_, 2001, still unpublished, linebreaks reproduced inexactly below)
humming embers
a plangent parody of dirth
and all that’s dug up
flightless sparrows swell in hunger
sorrow
only sleeping later
when whimpering wettens wussy pillows
………………………………………………………………………………………….
[ _Book 1_, handwritten on legal-size music paper , is a beautiful object. The words, with their gorgeous phonic echoes, hang like fruits off the staves, in arrangements not so different than the ones you might see on trees. Intuitive and natural. Quince blossoms. Dew. Is nature not the ultimate ornament? Alan may have recently entered his most ornamental period. What do you all think?]
Kevin, you’re absolutely right, Alan does “want to get at the stripped-down emotional ‘facts’ of what’s in front of him to write”, and it is in those most stripped-down moments that his writing is perhaps the least ornamented. But it’s often, at those bare moments, thought-provoking, moving, seductive, severe, edgy, heartbreaking, funny, coarse, vulnerable, and totally compelling. I never said I *only* liked ornamental writing. I like VIBRANT writing. His writing is vibrant (cf Takahashi, below). It’s vibrant and it’s so terrifically… *yearny*. He’s also one of the few writers of his generation to acknowledge the importance of the reader, I mean of directly addressing the reader. So when I read his writing I really feel like he’s talking to me.
I feel like I’ve said about 1/16 of what I need to say about Alan’s work. But I have to stop for today. I want to make some chili. And the melancholy yak really needs a nap.